How to Judge a Grain Marketing Advisor's Track Record

Every advisor has a good story. A track record is only useful if you can check it, and if you read it next to its limits. Here is how to read one, starting with Klarenbach's.

Who this is for

Skeptical farmers and traders in Saskatchewan, Alberta, and the US Midwest.

Start with the limit

The limit comes from a 2020 Purdue University article by James Mintert, quoted in the first question below. Look for dated, specific calls, not just a best-year headline.

What Klarenbach publishes

The pricing FAQ says the marketing decisions stay with the reader, so positive returns can't be guaranteed.

The case studies page has individual calls, including durum, canola, and CWRS. Check them yourself.

What the fee is

Try any report free for 30 days on an annual plan. Current prices are on the pricing page. No refunds after the trial. Portfolio Consulting is priced by consultation.

Questions

Can any advisor consistently call market tops and bottoms?

No. In a 2020 Purdue University article, James Mintert wrote that there is no empirical evidence any individual advisor or firm can consistently identify market tops or bottoms over long periods. Read every track record with that in mind.

What does Klarenbach publish as its record?

The case studies page shows individual dated calls, including durum, canola, and CWRS. Those are historical narratives, not a forecast.

How can I test a track record before paying?

Annual Klarenbach plans start with a free 30-day trial, so you can read the signals live before you pay. There are no refunds after the trial.

What to do next

Grain Report trialSpecial Crops Report trial

About the author: Trent Klarenbach, BSA AgEc, PAg, Founder and Lead Analyst, Klarenbach Research. Trent operated a large farm for its time near Eatonia, SK, and has spent 11 years applying technical analysis to Prairie grain marketing.

More about Trent Klarenbach

Last reviewed: October 19, 2026

Klarenbach Research logo

Grab your FREE copy of The 2024 SK, AB, and Iowa Farmland Value Studies!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
X